A great interview by Laura Spinney in New Scientist magazine (issue 2934 | September 14 – 20, 2013) worth reading. David Howes directs the Centre for Sensory Studies at Concordia University in Montreal, Canada. His upcoming book, with Constance Classen, is Ways of Sensing: Understanding the senses in society (Taylor & Francis).
With every more pressure to vie for consumer attention, marketers are trademarking in new sensory territory, explains anthropologist David Howes
How are marketers exploiting our senses in new ways?
We’re seeing a rise in multisensory marketing, whereby more of the senses – sometimes all five simultaneously – are recruited to sell a product. Hotel chains have signature scents; Starbucks has soundtracks to complement the flavour of its coffee. In the past, most marketing passed through the aural and visual channels, and the other senses were neglected. Now the idea is that, with so much competition for consumers’ attention, no sense should be left unturned.
In what ways do our senses overlap in our experiences of consumer goods?
It’s about associations. Over time, for example, people came to associate the particular shade of blue used by Tiffany’s jewellers with luxury. Likewise, in the UK, purple sells chocolate because those who have grown up around Cadbury’s Dairy Milk bars associate the colour with gustatory pleasure. Another example is Corona beer. A study by my team indicated that its popularity among women has to do with the fact that Corona is considered light. It’s not technically a light beer, but it comes in a tall, clear bottle and is the colour of sunshine. We have a name for such cross-sensory associations: synaesthesia.
By synaesthesia, do you mean the rare neurological condition in which sensory pathways are linked, so people might taste shapes or associate letters with specific colours?
That’s how it is usually described, but synaesthesia also has cultural manifestations. From a marketing point of view those are the most interesting. In “pure” synaesthetes – those with the neurological condition – the sensory connections tend to be highly idiosyncratic, differing between individuals. Cultural associations, on the other hand, are shared by populations.
What are examples of cultural synaesthesia?
In China, the colour white is often identified with a harsh, foul odour. In the West, white is usually identified with soft, sweet smells. Such cultural associations can change over time. Mint was perceived as heating and drying in Western cultures prior to the modern era, now it’s more likely to be perceived as cooling and refreshing. And some associations may be universal. To take a well-documented example, most people would say that the word “maluma” sounds like a curvy shape, while “takete” sounds like a sharp-edged one.
To some extent, haven’t marketers always exploited these types of associations?
In the past, marketers may have hit on successful combinations intuitively, or by chance. So this showed up in slogans such as “Taste the rainbow” for Skittles sweets, or “Hear the big picture”, the tag line for Canada’s national radio broadcaster. The idea was simply to catch people’s attention by presenting them with a logical conundrum. Later, sensory stimuli were combined in culturally relevant ways. An example is the US dairy producers’ “Got milk?” poster campaign, which depicts celebrities with milk moustaches. In 2006, a twist was added when the scent of cookies was diffused in bus shelters in San Francisco where posters were displayed, to capitalise on the milk-cookie association in American culture.
So this strategy is becoming more deliberate?
These associations are now being investigated more systematically. Marketers want to know why they work. Sometimes this happens retrospectively. To investigate why Corona was popular among women, for instance, we hung out in bars, entered into casual conversations and paid close attention to people’s gestures as well as their words. We noticed that women often rubbed their thumb and forefingers together when speaking of what they liked about Corona. This suggested fineness, delicacy. Our research suggested that their preference was down to shape and colour.
From now on, will companies be employing people to simply observe us?
They already are. Ethnography – the scientific study of culture – is now emerging as the research method of choice, over focus groups and interviews. It goes beyond what people say, to explore how they actually behave in everyday settings. This allows ethnographers to uncover the implicit perceptual categories that people use to order the world of goods – as in the Corona example. Another famous example is the practice of adding weight to remote controls, after manufacturers discovered that users tended to perceive heavier remotes as being of higher quality.
Does sensory cross-referencing ever backfire?
Yes. Take the “Got milk?” ad campaign in San Francisco bus shelters. Themarketers hoped the association with the cookie scent would be irresistible, but interestingly, a lot of people complained. They felt it encouraged overeating, and that it was insensitive to homeless people. In another case, responding to a perceived consumer desire for purity, Pepsi marketed a clear cola drink in the 1990s with the slogan, “You’ve never seen a taste like this”. The idea proved popular in the lab, but failed in the real world because people associate cola flavour with a dark, rich colour, so they associated no colour with less flavour. Marketers are now realising that, to avoid these kinds of mistakes, it is important to conduct fieldwork first.
What other fieldwork has been done to investigate these cross-sensory associations?
My colleague Bianca Grohmann has studied how background music and ambient scent together influence people’s perceptions of shops at Christmas time, for example. When combined with tracks from Christmas albums, room sprays that people associate with the holiday enhanced positive evaluation of a store and its merchandise. But, if either the scent or the music was not considered Christmassy – if the combination was perceived as incongruent – there was no such enhancing effect.
Is more of this kind of research now happening prospectively?
Yes. Researchers at the University of Mainz in Germany have determined, for example, that the colour red suggests sweetness – at least to Westerners. They had participants taste white wine served in black glasses under different ambient lighting – red, blue, green or white. It was the same wine, but they said it tasted 50 per cent sweeter in red light compared with blue or white light. Obviously, this could have implications for the colour and packaging of products, and even for the retail site.
Are companies increasingly staking claims on things like scents and colours?
It used to be you trademarked brand names and logos. But now, trademark protection has been extended to colours, shapes, sounds and scents. This started in earnest in the 1990s. To use the earlier examples: Tiffany’s had been using its shade of blue since 1845, but trademarked it in 1998. Last year, Cadbury won a long legal battle to trademark the purple wrapping of Dairy Milk. These are associations that both companies don’t want other brands to take advantage of. Our sensory world is being divvied up and privatised, limiting the palette for a marketer fresh on the scene.
How easy is it to trademark across the senses?
It doesn’t always work. Harley-Davidson tried to trademark the “hog” sound of its motorcycle engines revving, but the application was turned down on the grounds that the sound was not distinctive enough.
Even so, are these cultural links between the senses the next land rush for marketers?
Potentially, synaesthesia offers advertisers a way round the trademark problem. If they can establish a cross-sensory correspondence, then even though they can’t use a certain colour, say, they may be able to suggest it indirectly through a sound, texture or taste.